The United States on Thursday brought a complaint against China in the World Trade Organization over tax policies that it said represent an "unfair barrier" to China's semiconductor imports.
"As a WTO member, China must live up to its WTO obligations. It cannot impose measures that discriminate against US products," said US Trade Representative Robert Zoellick. "US manufacturers of semiconductors and other products have a right to compete on a level playing field with Chinese firms."
There was no immediate response from China's Ministry of Commerce.
The US case was the first against China since it joined the WTO in December 2001. It followed criticism by Democratic presidential candidate John Kerry that President Bush's administration has not done enough to enforce the commitments China made when it was admitted to the trade body.
US Senate Finance Committee Chairman Charles Grassley said the trade complaint signaled that Washington's two-year "honeymoon" with China since it joined the WTO was over.
"The message here is simple. China has to comply with its international trade obligations," the top Iowa Republican said. The House of Representative's Democratic watchdog on trade described the action as long overdue.
"One case brought as a political talking point does not make up for the administration's failure to develop a China trade policy over the past three years while ... the US has lost almost 3 million manufacturing jobs," said Representative Sander Levin, a Michigan Democrat.
American semiconductor companies complain that China gives its domestic producers an unfair advantage in the US$19 billion Chinese semiconductor market, by providing big rebates on a 17 percent value-added tax.
Last year, American companies exported US$2.02 billion worth of semiconductors to China and paid about US$344 million in value-added taxes. US claims that Chinese semiconductor companies receiving a tax rebate of about 80 percent, had an effective tax rate of as little as 3 percent, US officials said.
Zoellick defended the US administration's handling of trade with China, which ran a record of more than US$120 billion surplus with the United States last year, as the United States alleges. The United States has made substantial progress on disputes with China in areas like agricultural biotechnology, express delivery, insurance and auto finance, without having to go to the WTO, Zoellick said.
"These discussions will continue because we prefer compliance rather than litigation. However, the bottom line is that China is discriminating against key US technology products. It's wrong, and it's time to pursue a remedy through the WTO," Zoellick said.
Washington's action formally begins a 60-day period for the two countries to try to resolve the issue between themselves.
(China Daily March 19, 2004)
